Defenders alone cannot win
Red has two advisors, two elephants and a general. Black has only a general. Red is far ahead in material, but no Red piece can ever attack.
Movesg0e2 e9d9 e2c4
- g0e2 An elephant steps up. There is no way to get closer: elephants stop at the river.
- e9d9 Black's general walks freely around its palace.
- e2c4 Red's elephant reaches the river line and can go no further. The rules treat this as a draw by insufficient material: neither side has a piece that can attack.
Both sides only have defenders
Both sides have only a general, an advisor and elephants. Neither can attack, so the game cannot be won by anybody.
Movesg0e2 e9d9 e2c4
- g0e2 Red moves an elephant. Nothing is threatened, and nothing can be.
- e9d9 Black's general steps to d9. Neither player can approach.
- e2c4 The elephant reaches the river. This is a dead draw: neither side has any attacking piece.
Not every endgame is winnable. To checkmate you need a piece that can attack the enemy general, and advisors and elephants cannot. Advisors stay inside the palace; elephants never cross the river. So a side that has only a general, advisors and elephants has no way of ever giving check.
What follows
- If neither side has an attacking piece (chariot, horse, cannon or soldier), the game is a draw.
- A lone general against defenders alone is a draw, however many advisors and elephants the other side has.
- Material counted in points is misleading here: advisors and elephants are worth something only if you have an attacker to go with them.
This matters when you plan trades. Before you trade your last attacker, make sure the pieces you keep are not only defenders.